Garrett Insurance

Garrett Insurance logo

Hill City, Kansas

Hill City Insurance Agency: Your Trusted Partner in Safeguarding What Matters Most

Business, Home, and Auto Insurance for You, Your Family, and Your Business


Let Garrett Insurance give you the Peace of Mind to Enjoy Life.

We are a family-owned and operated Hill City Independent Insurance Agency offering a variety of commercial and personal insurance and risk management solutions. Garrett Insurance started in Kerrville, TX over 100 years, and have expanded throughout Texas and Kansas. We’ve helped local businesses and families make sure they have coverage when it matters most. Formerly known in Hill City as WinHill Insurance Agency and founded by Colleen and Jeff Hardiek the Hill City, Kansas location merged with Garrett Insurance in 2022 to offer expanded products and services to our clients. The result of this merger was access to new insurance companies, new insurance products and better service processes.

Garrett Insurance - Hill City

As an independent insurance agency, we have the ability to shop your insurance needs among over 30 insurance companies that offer a wide range of products to tailor your insurance to your needs while competing for the best value as well. Our Kansas locations and staff have received numerous awards and recognition locally and statewide. Serving your insurance needs from the Hill City, Kansas location are Colleen Hardiek, Agent; Baylee Pfeifer, Agent; Justine Benoit, Agent.


As an independent agency we provide insurance of all kinds for families, farmers, commercial businesses, and health/life/employee benefits. Call us today for a quote customized for your specific needs.

Commercial Insurance Products

Personal Insurance Products


The Hill City, Kansas Insurance Agency for YOU.

As part of the Garrett Insurance family, you won’t just get an insurance policy. You’ll receive the BEST protection for your specific needs through our partnerships with leading insurance providers. We also take an active risk management role by helping our clients file and manage claims. Whether you are interested in protecting your family or safeguarding your business, we can find the right coverage to protect what’s yours.



We welcome an opportunity to tell you more about our agency, please contact us or give us a call. You can request a quote if you’re ready to get started.




Insurance Excellence Since 1918

independent insurance agenttrusted choice

Garrett Insurance
Hill City

110 E Main Street
Hill City, Kansas 67642
Phone: (785) 421 2127
Office Hours: 8am-4:30pm M-F


Accessibility Toolbar

Scroll to Top