Garrett Insurance

Garrett Insurance logo
Texas Locations

Kansas Locations

Do You Pay Federal Taxes on Insurance Payments?

Do You Pay Federal Taxes on Insurance Payments - Garrett Insurance

After an accident, your insurance provider may submit a reimbursement payment for the covered claim, and though that can certainly be helpful at that moment, you may wonder what it means for you when it comes to tax season and whether you’ll have to pay federal taxes on personal or commercial insurance payments.

Generally, the IRS does not count reimbursement payments as taxable income, at least as long as they’re intended to make you whole, but there are some cases in which you will owe tax on insurance payments. Here’s how to make sense of each type.

Do You Pay Taxes on Personal Insurance Payments?

The IRS does not regard insurance payments as taxable income as long as these payments cover a loss, such as damage or theft. 

Insurance policies are designed to make you whole, not to build on your wealth, and that means you won’t owe taxes on any reimbursement used in a restorative capacity; for example, if your auto insurance provider pays for your car to be repaired following an accident, the money they provide will not be subject to income tax. 

However, there are some examples where you may be asked to pay tax on insurance payments, such as any situation in which your insurance payment increases your wealth as opposed to simply restoring your financial position to what it was prior to the covered incident.

Excess Insurance Payments

If your insurance payout exceeds the value of the actual loss, that excess may be considered taxable income. Imagine, for example, that one of your vehicles is damaged, and your insurance provider pays $10,000 for repairs; if the actual repairs only cost you $8,500, the $1,500 that is left over would be deemed taxable.

Life Insurance Payments

In general, federal taxes are not levied on life insurance payouts. The proceeds from a life insurance policy are typically considered tax-free income, providing financial support to beneficiaries without incurring additional tax obligations. However, there are some exceptions and nuances to this rule.

When Do I Pay Tax on Commercial Insurance Payments?

Similar to personal insurance, the IRS does not generally categorize commercial insurance payments as taxable income so long as the money is being provided to financially restore you after a loss or case of theft. 

A common example scenario is when a business receives insurance reimbursements for losses such as property damage, theft, or other covered events; these payments are intended to restore the business to its financial position prior to the incident and are, therefore, not classified as taxable income.

However, there are several cases in which business owners can be expected to pay tax on insurance payments; these vary according to policy type:

Business Interruption Insurance

Business interruption insurance is a specialized policy that covers your profits following a covered event, but given that these payments are intended to replicate your actual business income, they can be taxed at your usual rate. 

Excess Insurance Payments

Just as it is with personal insurance, if your commercial insurance provider reimburses you for more than the damages incurred, the excess can be taxed. As such, if a commercial vehicle is damaged and your provider sends you a check for $15,000, but the actual damages are only worth $12,000 to fix, you will pay tax on the $3,000 that is left over.

Reimbursements for Deducted Loss

If you deduct a business loss but still receive an insurance reimbursement, that reimbursement amount will count as taxable income since you’ve already received a tax break from the loss in the form of a business deduction. 

That also applies to the cost of insurance premiums, which business owners commonly deduct; if your insurance carrier reimburses you for any of these premiums, the payment will have to be reported as a type of business income. 

Interest on Insurance Payments

In some cases, your commercial insurance provider will issue you a settlement that includes interest. When that happens, the interest portion of the payment will be taxed, while the rest of the insurance payout will be excluded from your taxable income. Granted, interest payments are relatively small, but they must still be reported to the IRS to maintain legal and regulatory compliance.

Do I Pay Tax on Insurance if I’m Self-Employed?

If you’re a solo entrepreneur or a freelancer, you may wonder whether you must pay taxes on your insurance payments. The same principles apply to you; any insurance payment you receive to reimburse you for damage or theft will not be taxed, though you will need to pay taxes on any insurance payments you might receive to reimburse you for medical or dental bills.

Additionally, as with the categories above, you will pay tax on any insurance payments that go beyond mere reimbursement. If you use commercial business interruption insurance for your small business, you will owe taxes on these insurance payouts. 

Bottom Line: When Is Insurance Taxed?

The bottom line is as such: Payments that are meant to reimburse you or make you whole are not taxable, according to the IRS. It is only when you receive an amount that does more than restore your finances or business that you will be taxed. It’s advisable to consult with a tax professional to fully understand the specific circumstances and ensure compliance with current tax regulations.

At Garrett Insurance, we’re proud to offer a wide range of insurance products. We’ve been in the business of insurance for over 100 years, and our company history and combined knowledge enable us to deliver exceptional products and services. If you’re looking to find the right insurance policy for the right price, don’t hesitate to contact us today for a free quote.

Accessibility Toolbar

Scroll to Top